Explore Magro’s Pizzeria Menu in Norwich, NY (Oct 2025) – Authentic Italian Pizza & More With Prices

Looking for authentic Italian pizza and traditional dishes in New York? Explore Magro's Pizzeria's menu at 102 E Main St, Norwich, featuring updated prices, customer reviews, and must-try dishes like hand-tossed pizzas, calzones, Italian entrees, and more!

Magro’s Pizzeria, located at 102 E Main St, Norwich, NY 13815, is a beloved family-owned establishment that invites you to explore the delicious world of authentic Italian cuisine! Known for its hand-tossed pizzas and traditional Italian flavors, Magro’s Pizzeria stands out as one of the best Italian restaurants in Norwich with its signature dishes like specialty pizzas, fresh calzones, and classic Italian entrees. Whether you’re into traditional pizza or prefer authentic Italian pasta dishes, there’s plenty to choose from at this local favorite pizzeria.

Magro’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices (Updated)

Magro's Pizzeria Menu in Norwich, NY

Magro’s Pizzeria is renowned for its traditional Italian flavors, with each dish being a celebration of authentic Italian cooking. Here’s a comprehensive look at their menu:

Hand-Tossed Pizzas

Experience authentic Italian pizza with fresh ingredients and traditional preparation methods. Magro’s Pizzeria’s pizza selection features hand-tossed dough and quality toppings that capture the essence of traditional Italian pizzerias.

Pizza Size/TypePriceCalories (Est.)
Small Plain Pizza (12")$12.941200-1400
Medium Plain Pizza (14")$15.941600-1800
Large Plain Pizza (16")$18.942000-2200
Pepperoni Pizza (Large)$21.942200-2400
Sausage & Pepper Pizza$22.942300-2500
Supreme Pizza$25.942500-2700
Margherita Pizza$20.942000-2200
White Pizza$19.941900-2100

Calzones & Strombolis

Traditional Italian folded pizzas stuffed with delicious ingredients and fresh ricotta cheese. Magro’s calzone selection offers hearty portions with authentic Italian flavors that provide a satisfying alternative to traditional pizza.

ItemPriceCalories (Est.)
Cheese Calzone$12.99700-850
Pepperoni Calzone$14.99800-950
Sausage & Pepper Calzone$15.99850-1000
Veggie Calzone$14.99650-800
Meat Lovers Calzone$17.991000-1200
Stromboli$13.99750-900

Italian Entrees & Pasta

Classic Italian dishes prepared with traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. Magro’s pasta selection features authentic Italian sauces and quality ingredients that bring the taste of Italy to Norwich.

DishPriceCalories (Est.)
Spaghetti & Meatballs$14.99800-950
Chicken Parmigiana$16.99850-1000
Eggplant Parmigiana$15.99700-850
Fettuccine Alfredo$13.99900-1100
Lasagna$15.99800-950
Baked Ziti$13.99700-850
Chicken Marsala$17.99750-900
Veal Parmigiana$19.99900-1050

Appetizers & Starters

Perfect starters to begin your Italian dining experience. Magro’s appetizer selection brings traditional Italian flavors that prepare your palate for the main course with authentic taste and quality ingredients.

ItemPriceCalories (Est.)
Garlic Bread$5.99300-400
Mozzarella Sticks$8.99500-650
Buffalo Wings (10pc)$11.99750-900
Antipasto Platter$12.99600-750
Bruschetta$7.99250-350
Fried Calamari$10.99400-550
Stuffed Mushrooms$8.99300-450

Salads & Soups

Fresh salads and traditional Italian soups that complement every meal perfectly. Magro’s salad selection features crisp vegetables and authentic Italian dressings that provide a healthy start to your dining experience.

ItemPriceCalories (Est.)
House Salad$6.99150-250
Caesar Salad$8.99300-450
Antipasto Salad$11.99400-550
Greek Salad$9.99250-400
Pasta Fagioli Soup$4.99200-300
Minestrone Soup$4.99150-250
Italian Wedding Soup$5.99250-350

Desserts

End your Italian meal with traditional sweets and classic desserts. Magro’s dessert menu offers authentic Italian treats that provide the perfect finish to your traditional Italian dining experience.

DessertPriceCalories (Est.)
Tiramisu$6.99400-500
Cannoli (2pc)$5.99350-450
Cheesecake$5.99400-500
Italian Ice$3.99150-200
Gelato (3 scoops)$4.99300-400

Beverages

Refresh yourself with Magro’s beverage selection. From Italian sodas to classic drinks, these beverages perfectly complement the rich flavors of authentic Italian cuisine.

BeveragePriceCalories (Est.)
Italian Soda$3.99120-180
Soft Drinks$2.99140-180
Coffee$2.495-10
Cappuccino$3.9980-120
Iced Tea$2.995-10
Lemonade$2.99120-150
Water$1.990

Magro's Pizzeria Menu in Norwich, NY

What Makes Magro’s Pizzeria a Favorite in Norwich?

Magro’s Pizzeria is a must-visit restaurant in Norwich for several reasons. The authentic Italian atmosphere, combined with traditional hand-tossed pizza preparation, creates a unique dining experience. Guests often rave about the family-owned hospitality and generous portions, making it a favorite spot for those who love genuine Italian cuisine and pizza.

Magro’s Pizzeria is a family-owned business known for their hand-tossed pizzas and authentic Italian cuisine, rated 5.0 of 5 on TripAdvisor and ranked #21 of 25 restaurants in Norwich. Here’s what sets it apart:

  • Hand-Tossed Pizza Tradition – Authentic Italian pizza-making methods
  • Family-Owned Heritage – Personal touch with traditional recipes
  • Fresh Ingredients – Quality toppings and authentic Italian flavors
  • Cozy Main Street Location – Welcoming neighborhood pizzeria atmosphere

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a leisurely Italian meal, Magro’s Pizzeria provides a welcoming space to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine with an atmosphere that enhances the traditional pizzeria experience.

Updated Timings for Magro’s Pizzeria

Based on current operating hours from Yelp:

DayHours
Monday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
SundayClosed

Magro’s Pizzeria Features and Contact Details

For those planning to visit or inquire about Magro’s Pizzeria, here are the key features and contact information:

FeatureDetails
Location102 E Main St, Norwich, NY 13815, United States
PhoneContact for current number
CuisineItalian, Pizza, Calzones, Pasta
Restaurant TypeFamily-Owned Pizzeria
MealsLunch, Dinner
Takeout & DeliveryAvailable
SeatingDine-In Available
Service StyleCasual Dining
AtmosphereFamily-Friendly Italian

What Makes Magro’s Pizzeria Stand Out in New York?

Magro’s Pizzeria stands out in New York for its commitment to authentic Italian pizza culture and traditional hand-tossed preparation methods. The restaurant brings a genuine Italian pizzeria experience to diners with its focus on quality ingredients and time-honored Italian recipes.

Magro’s Pizzeria is a cozy eatery in Norwich, NY, known for serving up delicious pizzas and Italian dishes with a casual atmosphere and friendly service. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita pizza or hearty pasta dishes, each item reflects the rich culinary traditions of Italian cuisine. You absolutely have to try their signature hand-tossed pizza with fresh toppings – it’s a total local favorite! And if you want to complete your meal, grab a cappuccino – it’s the perfect Italian beverage that pairs beautifully with everything on the traditional menu.

Customer Reviews For Magro’s Pizzeria in Norwich, NY

“Amazing pizza with that authentic Italian taste! The crust is perfectly hand-tossed and the service is always friendly and welcoming.” – Maria S.

“This place has become our go-to spot for Italian food. The calzones are huge and delicious, and you can really taste the quality ingredients!” – Tom R.

“Great family-owned pizzeria with a cozy atmosphere. The pasta dishes are excellent and the portions are very generous for the price.” – Lisa M.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does Magro’s Pizzeria offer vegetarian options?
Yes! Magro’s Pizzeria offers several vegetarian options including cheese pizza, veggie calzones, eggplant parmigiana, and various pasta dishes with marinara or alfredo sauce.

Q: Is there a kids’ menu available?
While Magro’s doesn’t have a specific kids’ menu, they offer kid-friendly options like plain cheese pizza, spaghetti with marinara sauce, and chicken fingers that are perfect for younger diners.

Q: Does Magro’s Pizzeria offer delivery services?
Yes, Magro’s Pizzeria offers both takeout and delivery options, so you can enjoy their authentic Italian dishes at home.

Key Takeaways

Magro’s Pizzeria is an excellent destination for those wanting to experience authentic Italian pizza and traditional cuisine. If you love hand-tossed pizza, fresh calzones, or classic pasta dishes, you’ll find plenty of options to satisfy your cravings. The restaurant has a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere that makes it ideal for a casual meal with friends or family.

Pro Tip: If it’s your first visit, start with their signature hand-tossed pizza and a classic calzone for an authentic Italian experience. Pair it with a cappuccino and traditional Italian sides to complete your meal the Italian way!

If you are looking for Mouthewatering American Food then look at our Route 501 Roadhouse Menu.

At Pinnafy, our editorial team is made up of locals who love exploring neighborhoods, trying new spots, and shining a light on small businesses that make each community unique. We’re writers, foodies, and everyday people who believe in keeping things simple, honest, and helpful. Whether we’re sharing a new café that just opened down the street or highlighting the best local services in your area, we aim to create content that actually makes your day-to-day better. Everything we publish is researched with care and written with one goal in mind — to help you discover what’s nearby, easily and confidently.