Why Is Gino’s Italian Deli Menu Madison WI Ranked #164 with 4.6/5 Stars? Updated Guide with Prices (Oct 2025)

Are you searching for authentic Italian deli sandwiches and homemade lasagna in Madison? Gino's Italian Deli delivers fresh quality ingredients with made-to-order sandwiches, take-home meals, and signature Italian specialties that earned it 4.6 out of 5 stars on TripAdvisor and ranking as one of Madison's best Italian delis!

Gino's Italian Deli Menu Madison WI

Gino’s Italian Deli operates at 4606 Verona Rd, Madison, WI 53711, serving as a distinctive family-owned delicatessen where freshness and quality ingredients make for delicious products. This authentic Italian deli specializes in made-in-house daily preparations including deli salads, pasta sauces, Gino’s famous lasagna, homemade meatballs, Italian sausage, submarine sandwiches, and take-and-bake meals that create vibrant Italian flavors in a casual atmosphere perfect for families and groups.

What Time Does Gino’s Italian Deli Open Today?

Gino’s Italian Deli operates with extended hours throughout the week to accommodate lunch and dinner crowds:

DayOperating Hours
Monday - Saturday9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Call (608) 271-2420 to confirm daily hours, place takeout orders, or inquire about catering services for large groups

Gino’s Italian Deli Menu With Current Prices

Gino's Italian Deli Menu Madison WI

Gino’s Italian Deli established itself as Madison’s premier family-owned Italian delicatessen by focusing on freshness, quality ingredients, and made-in-house daily preparations that create authentic Italian experiences with competitive pricing for families and Italian food enthusiasts.

Why Do People Love Gino’s Madison Location?

Gino’s Italian Deli attracts loyal customers with authentic Italian preparation methods and family-owned hospitality:

Family Favorite FeaturesCustomer AppealWhat Sets Them Apart
Made-in-House DailyFresh pasta sauces, meatballs, sausageAuthentic Italian preparation methods
Famous Gino's LasagnaSignature dinner specialTraditional recipe perfected over years
Family-Owned ServiceDistinctive delicatessen experiencePersonal attention and quality consistency
Take-and-Bake OptionsConvenient home diningRestaurant quality at home

Famous Gino’s Lasagna and Dinner Specials

Experience Gino’s signature lasagna and traditional Italian dinner specials prepared with authentic recipes:

Dinner SpecialtiesPreparation StyleServing OptionsPrice Range
Gino's Famous LasagnaSignature homemade recipeIndividual, family, party portions$8.99 - $24.99
Italian Dinner CombosComplete meals with sidesIncludes bread and salad$12.99 - $18.99
Take-and-Bake LasagnaRestaurant quality at homeVarious sizes available$14.99 - $32.99
Family Party PortionsLarge quantity preparationsServes 6-12 people$35.99 - $65.99

Made-to-Order Italian Submarine Sandwiches

Enjoy authentic Italian submarine sandwiches prepared fresh with quality meats and ingredients:

Italian Sub OptionsSignature IngredientsSize OptionsCost Range
Italian SubCapicola, salami, ham, provoloneHalf or whole sandwich$6.99 - $12.99
Meatball SubHomemade meatballs, marinaraHalf or whole portions$7.99 - $13.99
Italian Sausage SubHouse-made Italian sausageFresh roll, peppers, onions$8.99 - $14.99
Veggie Italian SubFresh vegetables, Italian dressingVegetarian-friendly option$5.99 - $10.99

Homemade Meatballs and Italian Sausage

Discover signature preparations made in-house daily with traditional Italian recipes:

House-Made SpecialtiesTraditional PreparationServing StylePricing
Italian MeatballsMade fresh dailyBy the dozen or half-dozen$8.99 - $15.99
Italian SausageHouse-made dailyLinks or bulk preparation$6.99 - $12.99 per lb
Meat SauceHomemade with fresh ingredientsVarious container sizes$4.99 - $9.99
Combo PackagesMeatballs, sausage, sauceComplete Italian meal kit$18.99 - $29.99

Fresh Pasta Sauces and Deli Salads

Complete your Italian experience with fresh pasta sauces and deli salads prepared daily:

Fresh PreparationsTraditional MethodsContainer SizesPrice Range
Marinara SauceMade fresh dailyPint, quart, half-gallon$3.99 - $12.99
Meat SauceTraditional recipe with ground beefVarious sizes$4.99 - $15.99
Italian Pasta SaladFresh vegetables, Italian dressingDeli portions$6.99 - $12.99 per lb
Antipasto SaladItalian meats, cheeses, olivesFresh daily preparation$8.99 - $15.99 per lb

Daily Specials and Weekly Features

Discover rotating daily specials featuring Italian classics and seasonal preparations:

Daily SpecialsFeatured DaysSpecial PreparationsPrice Range
Monday SpecialsWeekly rotationPasta dishes, soup specials$7.99 - $13.99
Wednesday FeaturesMid-week favoritesItalian comfort food$8.99 - $14.99
Weekend SpecialsSaturday-SundayFamily-style preparations$12.99 - $22.99
Seasonal ItemsHoliday preparationsTraditional Italian celebrationsMarket pricing

How Much Does Gino’s Italian Deli Cost?

Gino’s Italian Deli maintains family-friendly pricing with most meals ranging $8-18 per person for authentic Italian experiences:

Meal CategoryAverage Cost Per PersonValue Features
Sandwich Meals$7 - $13Made-to-order, generous portions
Dinner Specials$10 - $18Complete meals with sides
Take-and-Bake Items$15 - $35Family portions, restaurant quality
Deli Items by Pound$7 - $16 per lbFresh daily preparations

Customer reports: “Food: 5 Price per person: $1–10” with “excellent place and my favorite in Madison”

Why Choose Gino’s Over Other Italian Places?

Gino’s Italian Deli distinguishes itself through authentic preparation methods and family ownership commitment:

  • Family-Owned Heritage: Distinctive family-owned delicatessen with personal attention and consistent quality standards.
  • Made-in-House Daily: Deli salads, pasta sauces, lasagna, meatballs, and Italian sausage prepared fresh daily using traditional methods.
  • Take-and-Bake Convenience: Restaurant-quality Italian meals available for convenient home preparation.
  • Multiple Location Access: Two convenient locations in Madison (Verona Rd) and Middleton (Century Ave) serve broader area.
  • Quality Ingredient Focus: Freshness and quality ingredients make for delicious products with authentic Italian flavors.

How to Order from Gino’s Italian Deli

Experience authentic Italian deli food through multiple convenient service options:

Service MethodContact InformationBest For
Dine-In Experience4606 Verona Rd, Madison, WI 53711Fresh sandwiches, casual atmosphere
Phone Orders(608) 271-2420Takeout, catering inquiries
Take-and-Bake OptionsAvailable dailyHome preparation, family meals
Catering ServicesCall for consultationLarge groups, special events

Gino's Italian Deli Menu With Prices

What Makes This Family-Owned Deli Special?

Gino’s Italian Deli distinguishes itself through authentic Italian traditions and community dedication:

  • Authentic Italian Heritage: True taste of Italy with traditional recipes and preparation methods passed down through Italian culinary traditions.
  • Fresh Daily Preparations: Everything made in-house daily ensures maximum freshness and authentic flavors in every dish.
  • Casual Family Atmosphere: Vibrant Italian flavors in casual atmosphere perfect for families and groups with outdoor seating available.
  • Take-Home Convenience: Take-and-bake meals provide restaurant-quality Italian dining at home with convenience.
  • Community Institution: 1,371 Facebook followers and strong local reputation as Madison area’s premier Italian delicatessen.

Real Customer Reviews and Experiences

Customer feedback reveals genuine experiences from Gino’s Italian Deli visitors across multiple review platforms:

Gino’s Italian Deli maintains 4.6 out of 5 stars from 31 reviews on TripAdvisor, ranked #164 of 699 restaurants in Madison, with 115 reviews on Yelp.

“Absolutely devoured the turkey and Swiss sandwich I got on my way home from surgery 10/10. Food: 5 Price per person: $1–10”

“Gino’s Italian Deli is excellent place and my favorite in Madison!”

Reviews consistently praise the authentic Italian preparation methods, fresh daily ingredients, and family-owned hospitality that creates memorable dining experiences.

The Middleton location maintains 4.5 out of 5 on Restaurant Guru with 664 reviews, demonstrating consistent quality across both locations.

Most Asked Questions About Gino’s Italian Deli

What time does Gino’s Italian Deli open and close?
Monday-Saturday 9:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Call (608) 271-2420 to confirm daily hours.

What makes Gino’s lasagna famous?
Gino’s famous lasagna uses traditional Italian recipes with fresh ingredients made in-house daily, available in individual, family, and party portions.

Do they offer take-and-bake meals?
Yes, take-and-bake meals provide restaurant-quality Italian food for convenient home preparation, including lasagna and other specialties.

Are there two Gino’s Italian Deli locations?
Yes, two locations serve the area: Madison at 4606 Verona Rd and Middleton at 6509 Century Ave with slightly different hours.

What Italian specialties are made in-house daily?
Deli salads, pasta sauces, lasagna, meatballs, and Italian sausage are all made fresh daily using traditional Italian methods.

Essential Information Before You Visit

Gino’s Italian Deli creates authentic Italian experiences through traditional preparation methods, quality ingredients, and family-owned hospitality. This distinctive delicatessen maintains Madison area reputation through consistent quality and fresh daily preparations.

Pro Tips for First Visitors: Try the famous Gino’s lasagna and Italian sub combo for authentic experience. Ask about take-and-bake options for convenient family meals. Call ahead for large catering orders or special preparations.

If you love spicy BBQ then look at our Hendrix Barbecue Menu.

At Pinnafy, our editorial team is made up of locals who love exploring neighborhoods, trying new spots, and shining a light on small businesses that make each community unique. We’re writers, foodies, and everyday people who believe in keeping things simple, honest, and helpful. Whether we’re sharing a new café that just opened down the street or highlighting the best local services in your area, we aim to create content that actually makes your day-to-day better. Everything we publish is researched with care and written with one goal in mind — to help you discover what’s nearby, easily and confidently.